And Then There Were None is the definition of a reliable, fast-paced classic, though it’s a different experience once you’ve been through it a few times. Having read it more than once now, it’s still an enjoyable ride, even if it doesn’t necessarily reveal new layers or teach you anything different on a second or third pass. Once the puzzle is solved, the magic shifts from the twist itself to the atmosphere.

A big part of what keeps it fun for me is the mental exercise of putting myself on Soldier Island and thinking through what I’d actually do in that situation. To be completely honest, the characters make plenty of choices I would never make if people were actively being murdered around me—wandering off alone or trusting the wrong person definitely makes you want to yell at the page a little.

Even with those classic mystery-trope decisions, Agatha Christie knows how to keep the pages turning. It’s always an easy, breezy read that flies by, and the eerie, locked-island setup makes it an ideal pick for an October book club.